helion-prime
home about us blogs contacts

Don’t use Google recaptcha

Published by vasiliy.kiryanov on June 10, 2011 under be smart, web-development  

preamble

Google reCAPTCHA is a great idea originally developed at Carnegie Mellon University by Guatemalan computer scientist Luis von Ahn. It uses captcha to help digitize the text of books while protecting websites from bots. According to Google reports it displays over 100 million captchas every day. Among its subscribers are such popular sites as: Facebook, Twitter, CNN.com, and StumbleUpon.

main drawback

So, main drawback is complexity of captchas. Captchas are getting more and more complex or even unreal to deal with. Just check twitter with query like “recaptcha” and you’ll see amazing amount of people that wonder what is going on.

number to think about

A number is 14%. According to my research on 2 our sites: http://prices.by and http://cartenergy.ru we were loosing about 14% of users on services sign-up while using REcaptcha.
The test was conducted using A/B testing where I vary our captcha and Google REcaptcha on sign-up page.

hint to google

Provide some parameter to select level of hardness, use of native languages is also a way to simplify solving while keep great security.

Be Sociable, Share!

Tags: ,

2 Responses to “Don’t use Google recaptcha”

  1. Philip Cole says:

    Thanks for suggestion. I will find some time in few days and replace REcaptcha with something custom in our products.

  2. Tom says:

    Actually, I’ve become convinced that REcaptcha has been taken over by folks doing testing of the limits of human perception. I think they have already digitized all the words in all the scanned books, now they are just testing how far they can push people’s pattern recognition skills.

Leave a Reply

©2010 Helion-Prime Solutions Ltd.
Custom Software Development Agile Company.